During
the readings this week I kept coming back to the same idea of "helicopter
parents" and "hovering teachers." As a student and as a
child I remember having a lot of time to explore, individually and with my
peers, to the point where I rarely remember having adults around except
for explicit lessons or times when an adult was mandatory. Most specifically I remember going to my
older brothers’ baseball games and tournaments and I would immediately leave my
parents to meet up with the other younger siblings from the teammates to wonder
around the baseball complex. We had to
keep an eye on the game so we could come back when the game was over, but
otherwise we were free to roam, get dirty and use our imagination. I remember it being a special activity to
have my parents play with me and my brothers but it was never expected. Now I see my nephews and nieces playing with
their parents more than learning to play with their own siblings. They are learning to play with adults who
stop them from making mistakes before they are even made. I’m a strong believer in learning from mistakes
so if students are not allowed the opportunity to make mistakes, how do we
expect our children to learn?
Learning
is a product of opportunities to expand and explore in one’s own time without
fear of judgment or overwhelming confinement.
All classrooms and societies have a set of laws and rules for safety and
consistency which provides an environment that allows for people to feel comfortable
to learn, but these should be basic necessities. Children have a sense of right and wrong,
which is why teachers typically know a student is about to do something inappropriate
because the student seeks out the teacher to check if they are looking. I’m sure all the teachers know this action,
when one of your students’ looks at you just before they do something probably
should not. They either do this to check
they are not going to get caught or they are seeking attention. That was a
question I had in the Japanese pre-school model for attention-seeking behaviors
that are not appropriate for the classroom, how does the teacher help students
develop socially so they do not act out or feel the need to act out? I completely agree with not intervening for
every misguided decision or disgruntled issue so students can develop together
and create stronger relationships, but when the behavior is meant to grab
attention will the behavior stop if it is ignored? Should the behavior have a scaffold lesson
facilitated by the teacher to help students understand how it is not the best
idea to act out?
Dear Sarah,
ReplyDeleteI found myself also thinking about students and learning from their mistakes while completing the readings for this week. I agree with you wholeheartedly that students and people learn from their mistakes and it can be one of the strongest learning tools. I have found in my classroom that students are so afraid of making a mistake or getting something wrong that they do not want to try unless they are absolutely sure they know the answer.
I have wondered a lot about where this inherent fear comes from. As you suggested, I do think that it comes from children being stopped before they make a mistake. They do not get the privilege of making a mistake and realizing that the world is not over. They simply need to try again. That is a motto I use in my classroom all the time, “Everyone makes mistakes. All you have to do is try again.” I find myself asking my students on a consistent basis what will happen if they make a mistake and it takes them a second to remember that nothing monstrous will happen.
I feel like the fear runs deeper than simply them not being afforded the opportunity to make mistakes. Unfortunately, I worry that society has made it so incredibly horrible to make a mistake. This is true for adults and children alike. I know that I am still guilty of it even though I know how fundamentally important mistakes are to learning. I do not want to make a mistake as it means that I am somehow a failure. I think this message is being sent to children as well in many different ways. I see the fear in many students’ eyes of what will my classmates and teacher think if I get the wrong answer. I would love to know a way that could help students to overcome this fear. I try to make my classroom a safe and loving environment for all students but it takes time for students to develop a level of comfort to really start taking risks. I begin to wonder if we need a school policy that follows children about making mistakes so that they can make the growth and continue it from year to year.
One other thing that struck me in your blog is the idea that you remember only being supervised during explicit lessons and such. I think of my classroom now and all it is instruction. There is no down time for students or for them just to be. I feel like both my and their days are filled with one subject or another at a pace that does not always allow for student learning to be maximized. There are times that I feel like I don’t have time to listen to a story from a student because of what has to get done. I have had many conversations with teachers in my building that we are not allocated time for students to have social experiences or nonacademic experiences in school. I worry that we are missing a huge learning opportunity here. Having these experiences in the classroom, allow for instruction to take place on how to deal with different circumstances. Some students pick up on how to deal people inherently but other students do not. They need someone to show them the way or to help them navigate the path. I feel like this learning has been removed from many schools.
Emily,
ReplyDeleteYou need to watch Carol Dweck's Growth Mindset project. (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kXhbtCcmsyQ The hyperlinks are not working in my reply so that is the link. The video is only 20 minutes long, not 40 as it would appear). In TE857 with Shannon Sweeny I learned all about how to implement a growth mindset into my classroom and it has really changed my classroom dynamic and teaching.
Hi Sarah,
ReplyDeleteThanks for your post. I enjoyed reading it!
I loved your stories about the baseball games when you were young. It is really interesting. We think about the formal activity as the whole point of things, but here is an example where what was happening at the fringe of the formal activity was the point of things--where learning was happening. I think school is the same way. We think about the formal curriculum as the place where learning happening, but the most powerful lessons often come at the fringes. I worry that the fringe space of school is being over-supervised and over-regulated these days.
I like the distinction you made near the end of your post between knowing kids and knowing what kids are up to. Really, if we put our attention on knowing kids, we can probably trust them to act wisely in most circumstances (or we can figure out who needs help in what sort of circumstances). I so want to view school as a place where adults mentor and counsel kids--not as a place where they watch and judge them. We are really a long way from that right now. But posts like yours give me hope that we might be moving more in that other direction.
Thanks again for your work!
Kyle